Fund: Smarter Money Fund - Base Fee Class |
Strategy: Smarter Money/Short-Term Fixed-Interest |
Return (since Feb. 2012): 4.30% pa gross (3.48% pa net) |
Net return volatility (since Feb. 2012): 0.59% pa |
Objective: An independently-rated/recommended strategy targeting low-risk cash and fixed-income returns that exceed the RBA’s cash rate by 1%-2% pa after fees, over rolling 12 month periods.
Strategy: We actively invest in a diversified portfolio of Australian deposits and investment grade floating-rate notes with a weighted-average “A” credit rating. We do not invest in fixed-rate bonds (unless interest rate risk is hedged), sub-investment grade bonds, direct loans, equities, capital notes, preference shares (eg, hybrids), use leverage, or take currency risk. We add value via active asset-selection using a range of valuation models with the aim of (1) delivering lower portfolio volatility than traditional bond funds and (2) providing superior risk-adjusted returns, or alpha, without explicitly seeking interest rate risk, credit risk or liquidity risk. The strategy is managed by Coolabah Capital Investments, which is a specialist active credit manager.
Period Ending 2024-12-31 | Gross Return (Base) | Net Return (Base)† | RBA Cash Rate | Gross Excess Return‡ | Net Excess Return (Assist.)†‡ |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 month | 0.60% | 0.53% | 0.37% | 0.23% | 0.16% |
3 months | 1.82% | 1.61% | 1.08% | 0.74% | 0.54% |
6 months | 3.38% | 2.96% | 2.19% | 1.19% | 0.78% |
1 year | 6.85% | 6.00% | 4.37% | 2.49% | 1.63% |
3 years pa | 4.95% | 4.12% | 3.13% | 1.82% | 1.00% |
5 years pa | 3.74% | 2.92% | 1.92% | 1.82% | 1.00% |
10 years pa | 3.67% | 2.85% | 1.76% | 1.91% | 1.09% |
Inception pa Feb. 2012 | 4.30% | 3.48% | 2.02% | 2.29% | 1.47% |
† Net returns are calculated from the historic gross returns using the current fee structure as displayed in the Product Disclosure Statement. ‡ The Excess Return columns represent the gross and net return above the RBA cash rate.
Ratings: Recommended (Zenith); Superior - Relatively Simple (Foresight Analytics) |
Fund: Smarter Money Fund - Base Fee Class |
Return/Risk: 4.30% pa gross/3.48% pa net (0.59% pa volatility) |
APIR Code | ETL6313AU | Fund Inception | 17-Feb-12 |
mFund Code | - | Distributions | Quarterly |
Asset-Class | Smarter Money/Short-Term Fixed-Interest | Unit Pricing | Daily (earnings accrue daily) |
Target Return | Net 1-2% pa over RBA cash rate | Min. Investment | $1,000 |
Investment Manager | Coolabah Capital Investments (Retail) | Withdrawals | Daily Requests (funds normally in 3 days) |
Responsible Entity | Equity Trustees | Buy/Sell Spread | 0.00%/0.025% |
Custodian | Citigroup | Mgt. & Admin Fee | 0.79% pa |
Fund: Smarter Money Fund - Base Fee Class |
Return/Risk: 4.30% pa gross/3.48% pa net (0.59% pa volatility) |
Portfolio commentary: In December, the zero-duration daily liquidity Smarter Money Fund (SMF) returned 0.60% gross (0.53% net), outperforming the RBA Overnight Cash Rate (0.37%), the AusBond Bank Bill Index (0.38%), the BetaShares High Interest Cash (AAA) ETF (0.39%), the FE Cash Enhanced Index (0.43%), and the AusBond Credit FRN Index (0.43%). Over the previous 12 months, SMF returned 6.85% gross (6.00% net), outperforming the RBA Overnight Cash Rate (4.37%), the AusBond Bank Bill Index (4.47%), the BetaShares High Interest Cash (AAA) ETF (4.58%), the FE Cash Enhanced Index (5.04%), and the AusBond Credit FRN Index (5.69%). SMF ended December with a running yield of 5.32% pa, a weighted-average credit rating of A+, and a portfolio weighted average MSCI ESG rating of AA.
Since the inception of SMF 12.9 years ago in February 2012, it has returned 4.30% pa gross (3.48% pa net), outperforming the RBA Overnight Cash Rate (2.02% pa), the AusBond Bank Bill Index (2.21% pa), the FE Cash Enhanced Index (2.42% pa), the BetaShares High Interest Cash (AAA) ETF (2.45% pa), and the AusBond Credit FRN Index (3.29% pa). Since inception, SMF's Sharpe Ratio, which measures risk-adjusted returns, has been 3.85x gross (2.48x net). While SMF's return volatility since inception has been low at around 0.59% pa (measured using daily returns), as a daily liquidity product with assets that are marked-to-market using executable prices, volatility does exist. This contrasts with illiquid credit (eg, loans and high yield bonds) wherein assets that have very high risk can appear to have remarkably low volatility, which is, in fact, just a mirage explained by the inability to properly value these assets using executable prices.
Strategy commentary: Looking back on 2024, Coolabah's strategies furnished both high absolute returns and substantial outperformance over benchmarks. Yet it was a year accented by extreme cross-currents. While central bank-controlled short-term policy rates did eventually decline, they failed to meet aggressive market expectations at the start of 2024 for very steep cuts.
Recall that the Fed was originally priced for as much as 175 basis points (bps) of rate reductions in 2024, yet only delivered 100bps. Alongside a nascent reacceleration in US inflation and the ascendency of Donald Trump, this contributed to higher long-term interest rates across the board as proxied by moves in 10-year government bond yields in the UK (+103bps), the US (+69bps), France (+64bps), Australia (+41bps), Germany (+34bps), and even in New Zealand (+9bps), which has been the throes of a real recession. One exception was Italy where long-term government bond yields declined by 13bps.
The higher-for-longer rate environment ostensibly created dramas in the sub-investment grade bond and private credit markets, which suffered one of the sharpest increases in defaults, restructurings and bankruptcies since the global financial crisis.
And this was a truly global phenomenon with the number of insolvencies reported in countries like the US, UK, Australia and New Zealand the worst since 2008. Despite the dramatic intensification in credit stresses in the riskier parts of debt markets, and never-ending media stories about private credit funds freezing as a consequence, spreads on both high-yield bonds and private loans remained remarkably tight.
The global risk rally in 2024 was amplified by central bank jaw-boning vis-à-vis their desire to ease the cost of capital, underscored by the unusual actions of the Fed to slash rates by 75 basis points immediately prior to, and then coincident with, a presidential election.
All of this echoed the positive influence on asset pricing that central bank communications had in late 2023 when the Fed initiated its original dovish pivot, which compelled markets to expect huge rate cuts in 2024 that would fail to materialise.
Overlay the hyperbole around the coming artificial intelligence revolution, as manifest in Nvidia's 171% total return in 2024, coupled with the market's one-eyed interpretation of Trump's policy proposals, and one had all the ingredients for yet another exuberant risk rally.
The Magnificent Seven accordingly soared 48% last year. Nvidia alone accounted for more than one-fifth and one-quarter of the total returns yielded by the S&P500 (+25%) and Nasdaq (+26%), respectively. Nvidia has, in fact, appreciated an astonishing 27,000% over the past decade.
Fund: Smarter Money Fund - Base Fee Class |
Return/Risk: 4.30% pa gross/3.48% pa net (0.59% pa volatility) |
Strategy commentary cont'd: The curious conjunction of persistent inflation fears, which did nothing to kibosh investor ebullience, was also potent for the performance of crypto (Bitcoin surged 123%) and gold, which appreciated a healthy 27%.
Here it is sobering to note that the US sharemarket has now returned more than 20% for two years in succession for the first time since 1998 and 1999. The late 1990s was similarly gripped by rhetoric around a tech-led "productivity miracle" that was going to completely disappear the business cycle. Hence we had the tech boom, which preceded the unexpected tech bust.
The practical reality was, therefore, far more grim: the US would plunge into recession in the early 2000s, which resulted in the S&P500 index posting total return losses of 9.1% in 2000 and 10.9% in 2001. This represented a cumulative drawdown of almost 20 per cent. The intra-year losses were a lot worse: the S&P500 sank a stunning 29% between January and September 2001.
It was a comparatively more sombre affair across the rest of the world with returns of less than half the US numbers in Europe (Eurostoxx 50 up 11.90%), Australia (the ASX200 up 11.44%), New Zealand (the NZX50 up 11.39%), and the UK (FTSE100 up 9.59%).
As we gaze ahead, investors should focus on the big questions: will a mercurial Trump roil markets and amplify volatility during his final term in power; will profligate political spending continue to crowd-out private activity; will inflation reaccelerate or normalise; will interest rates decline or rise again; will the default cycle deteriorate or modulate; and will the great powers of the world find themselves embroiled in kinetic conflict?
To accent the final point, China has unveiled not one, but two, sixth generation fighter jets in the new year. Officially, the US has yet to even decide if it will produce one. Unofficially, it has probably had several for years zipping around Area 51…
The juxtaposition of modest declines in short-term interest rates against sharp increases in long-term rates meant that floating-rate bond strategies materially outperformed their fixed-rate counterparts (where the latter suffered given that fixed-rate bond prices decline as yields rise).
So whereas the duration-hedged, or effectively floating-rate, Bloomberg Global Aggregate Corporate Index returned 8.60%, its long duration, or fixed-rate, equivalent only delivered 3.69% in 2024.
The floating-rate benchmark in Australia, which is the AusBond FRN Index, returned 5.69% in 2024, which is an attractive 1.34% margin above the RBA's cash rate (and circa 1% above bank deposit rates). This index similarly bested its fixed-rate alternative, the AusBond Composite Index, by 276bps.
Coolabah's most aggressive, daily liquidity, floating-rate strategies, which have average A+ credit ratings, also provided robust returns of circa 9-10% after retail fees (or 12-13% gross). In 2024, the Long Short Opportunities Fund returned 10.0% to 10.2% net of retail fees followed by the Long Short Credit Fund (9.6% to 9.8% after retail fees) and the Floating Rate High Yield Fund (9.0% to 9.2% net). Coolabah's more ambitious customised institutional mandates stretched further with total returns as high as 16.1% after fees.
On behalf of BetaShares, Coolabah manages Australia's largest active ETF, known as HBRD, which is a full capital structure investor in securities issued primarily by local banks and insurers in both Aussie dollars and foreign currencies, including cash securities, senior secured bonds, senior unsecured bonds, subordinated bonds, and hybrids.
In 2024, HBRD returned 7.80% after fees (inclusive of franking), beating passive floating-rate credit benchmarks, such as BetaShares' QPON product and Van Eck's FLOT, which returned 5.94% and 5.63% net of fees, respectively, in 2024.
HBRD also outperformed more aggressive passive floating-rate ETFs, such as Van Eck's popular SUBD, which only allocates to subordinated (known as Tier 2) bonds. In 2024, SUBD delivered 7.1% net.
Fund: Smarter Money Fund - Base Fee Class |
Return/Risk: 4.30% pa gross/3.48% pa net (0.59% pa volatility) |
Strategy commentary cont'd: Under HBRD's documentation, it is benchmarked against unfranked indices produced by Solactive, which track the performance of bank and insurer hybrid securities. Despite only being about 30% allocated to hybrids (the remaining 70% was invested in bonds), HBRD outperformed the Solactive benchmark by 92bps in 2024 after fees. Indeed, HBRD has beaten the major bank hybrid indices after fees since inception notwithstanding that it has been historically underinvested in the sector (and allocated to higher-ranking bonds).
Given APRA's decision to phase-out bank hybrids by 2032 (insurer hybrids will remain afoot), Coolabah expects HBRD's benchmark to be eventually upgraded to more appropriately reflect its current universe, which primarily amounts to investment-grade bonds issued by banks and insurers in Aussie dollars and global currencies, hedged back to AUD. Once again, we would note that HBRD will still have the capacity to allocate to insurer and corporate hybrids.
Coolabah's lowest risk floating-rate strategies are the daily liquidity, A+ rated Smarter Money and Short-Term Income funds (ETF: FRNS), which target returns of 1% and 1.5% above the RBA cash rate, respectively. In 2024, they delivered 6.0% after fees (6.9% gross) compared to cash rate's 4.37% and the AusBond FRN Index's 5.69%.
Coolabah's global long duration strategies also significantly outperformed their benchmarks, as evidenced by the 215bps of gross excess returns rendered by the Pacific Coolabah Global Active Bond strategy (5.45% versus 3.29% in GBP terms). This is particularly pleasing given that this strategy, which is not available to Australian investors, has a higher average A- rating than the index's BBB+ rating. It also carries the same 5.9 years duration as the index.
Staying in the long-duration, or fixed-rate, domain, Coolabah's domestic Active Composite Bond Fund (ETF: FIXD), which has a 5.1 year duration exposure, also comfortably beat its benchmark, the AusBond Composite Bond Index, by 288bps after fees (or by 367bps before fees). In absolute terms, FIXD returned 5.81% net (6.60% gross) compared to the index's 2.93%.
Finally, one of Coolabah's newest strategies, the AAA rated Active Sovereign Bond Fund, beat the RBA cash rate by 117bps in 2024 after fees (or by 217bps gross). The long-duration unit class, which is benchmarked against the AusBond Treasury Index, outperformed by 90bps net or 176bps gross. This is a unique solution that is designed to be extremely liquid by only allocating to Commonwealth government bonds with little correlation to equity or credit markets.
See enclosed below a summary of Coolabah's 12 month returns and current running yields as at 31 December 2024. Note that past performance is no guide to future returns. Please read the product PDS to better understand its risks and consult with an independent financial adviser prior to making decisions.
Fund: Smarter Money Fund - Base Fee Class |
Return/Risk: 4.30% pa gross/3.48% pa net (0.59% pa volatility) |
Strategy commentary cont'd:
Fund: Smarter Money Fund - Base Fee Class |
Return/Risk: 4.30% pa gross/3.48% pa net (0.59% pa volatility) |